The perfect extraction means...
...the Barista was able to extract the best out of the bean, not less, not too much.
All he needs is ground coffee, hot water and the balance of power :-)
But single origins are diverse, so the crema can have different colors and texture.
A professional Barista diagnoses the reason for those differences.
Underextraction
A too light crema can occure if the water has been to cool to have enough power to extract the sollubles and oils. A lower pump pressure can be cause, too. Or a too coarse groud that leads to a short contact time of water in the coffee. Anything that prevents the water from extracting with enough power leads to “under extraction” and therefore a lighter crema that disappears quickly.
The espresso tastes rather weak and the aromas couldn’t fully develop.
Overextraction
A too dark crema occurs from the opposite effects. Too much pressure dissolves too much solubles. Too much temperature burns the solubles. A too fine grind means a bigger surface and more extraction of solubles, additional to an extended extraction time which also leads to overleaching of the coffee. This all leads to a burnt surface and a burnt, bitter taste.
In the pic you see from the left to the right:
underextracted, prefect extracted and overextracted espressi.
Only judge the color when you know your coffee...
Coffees from Kenia have a lighter crema, coffees from India a darker crema.
Robustas have a darker redish crema, too.
Crema changes it's color every minute and darkens. So you can only judge the crema when it's fresh from the machine.
Too fresh coffee makes a lot crema, but too porous.
Old coffe hardly makes a crema anymore, as does coffee that was frozen before.